Sometimes those holes are too deep. Pete had me put 2 of the Allen screws on each side with lots of sealer. They are supposed to be a tapered thread for sealing but sometimes the shop doing it uses a straight thread.
I believe that's your culprit, Tbone. The evidence reveals a guilty verdict. I'm with Tony. Clean it up and re-install the screw with plenty of good thread sealer.
I just got this cylinder back from Arlan after I had it re-nikasiled.